Skip to main content

Top pie spots across the US and Canada

Birdie’s Pie Shop in Post Falls, ID – Photo by Bilal L

Pi: It’s that mathematical ratio of a circle’s radius to its circumference. In decimal form, it begins 3.14. 

Pie: That magical, circular dessert that radiates happiness from within its circumference and takes less than 3.14 seconds to devour.

Image courtesy Upper Crust Pie Bakery (Overland Park) via Yelp

Once a year, on Pi Day (3.14 is March 14th, get it?) these two phenomenon come together and we go banana cream to get our hands on the best slice of pie we can find.

This year, we cut through the Yelp data to find the top pie shops in every US State and Canadian province. Think of them as the upper crust. The (whipped) cream of the crop. 

Proper Pie (Richmond) by Kamille P

We limited our search to sweet pies in any sized round shape, or the trendy hand pies, but that doesn’t mean we don’t also love those savory pie shops we discovered along the way (looking at you, Waltzing Kangaroo). From berries to buttermilk, and chocolate to coconut cream, you’re sure to find a new pie spot to circle as your favorite!

You can see the selections below, then follow the Yelp Collections (US here, Canada here) so you have them saved wherever you go.

Image courtesy Pie Junkie (Calgary) via Yelp

 Top Pie Spot in Each US State:

Alabama – JaWanda’s Sweet Potato Pie (Birmingham)
Alaska – A Pie Stop (Anchorage)
Arizona – Squarz Bakery & Cafe (Tempe)
Arkansas – Rymolene’s Pies (Fayetteville)
California – The Giving Pies (San Jose)
Colorado – Showboat Drive By Pie (Granby)
Connecticut – Granny’s Pie Factory (East Hartford)
Delaware – Sweet Somethings (Wilmington)
District of Columbia – Whisked! (Washington DC)
Florida – Sweet Delights Key Lime Pies (Florida City)
Georgia – Panbury’s Double Crust Pies (Atlanta)
Hawaii – Annie’s Bake Shop (Aiea)
Idaho – Birdie’s Pie Shop (Post Falls)
Illinois – Pie Boss (Aurora)
Indiana – Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery (Danville)
Iowa – Kathy’s Pies (Cedar Rapids)
Kansas – Upper Crust Pie Bakery (Overland Park)
Kentucky – Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen (Louisville)
Louisiana – Bywater Bakery (New Orleans)
Maine – Two Fat Cats Bakery (Portland)
Maryland – Lancaster County Dutch Market (Germantown)
Massachusetts – Petsi Pies (Somerville)
Michigan – Sister Pie (Detroit)
Minnesota – Rustic Inn Cafe (Two Harbors)
Mississippi – The Dutch Oven (Clarksdale)
Missouri – Ashleigh’s Bake Shop (Kansas City)
Montana – The Coffee Pot Bakery Cafe (Bozeman)
Nebraska – Farm House Cafe (Omaha)
Nevada – Chef Flemming’s Bakeshop (Henderson)
New Hampshire – Woodstock Pie And Coffee (Woodstock)
New Jersey – Pie Lady Cafe (Moorestown)
New Mexico – The Village Buttery (Ruidoso)
New York – Two Little Red Hens (New York City)
North Carolina – Baked Pie Company (Asheville)
North Dakota – Nichole’s Fine Pastry & Café (Fargo)
Ohio – Dough Mama (Columbus)
Oklahoma – Pie Junkie (Oklahoma City)
Oregon – Pennington Farms (Grants Pass)
Pennsylvania – The Sweet Life Bakeshop (Philadelphia)
Rhode Island – Pastiche (Providence)
South Carolina – Handy & Hot (Charleston)
South Dakota – Queen City Bakery (Sioux Falls)
Tennessee – Magpies (Knoxville)
Texas – Fredericksburg Pie Company (Fredericksburg)
Utah – Flake Pie Co (South Jordan)
Vermont – The Southern Pie Cafe (Chester)
Virginia – Proper Pie (Richmond)
Washington – Baked From The Hart (Seattle)
West Virginia – Almost Heaven Desserts (Bridgeport)
Wisconsin – Wood Orchard Market (Egg Harbor)
Wyoming – The Bunnery Bakery & Restaurant (Jackson)

Top Pie Spot In Each Canadian Province:

Alberta – Pie Junkie (Calgary)
British Columbia – Peaked Pies (Whistler)
Manitoba – Baked Expectations (Winnipeg)
New Brunswick – Le Moulin A Cafe (Charlo)
Newfoundland and Labrador – The Old Loft Restaurant (Woody Point)
Nova Scotia – White Sails Bakery & Deli (Tantallon)
Ontario – The Pie Plate Bakery & Cafe (Virgil)
Prince Edward Island – Bread & Butter Bakery & Fine Pastries – Kingston
Quebec – Mamie Clafoutis (Montréal)
Saskatchewan – Konga Cafe (Saskatoon)

This is an all-time list of the best pie in every US state and Canada according to Yelp. We identified businesses in the pies category, then ranked those spots using a number of factors including the total volume and ratings of reviews. All businesses were marked open on Yelp as of March 8, 2021. When available, all businesses on this list have a passing health score as of March 8, 2021. (Data was inconclusive in Northwest Territories, Nunavut, and Yukon. Know a great pie spot there? Share it on Yelp!)