Skip to main content

Where to find the best pie in every state

Birdie’s Pie Shop (Post Falls, ID)

There are plenty of reasons to indulge in a slice of pie, but we’ll give you one more– March 14th is Pi Day, an annual celebration of the mathematical constant π. Celebrations often involve pie eating, so we’ve rounded up the top spot for pie in every state.

Methodology: This is an all-time list of the Top Pie in Every State according to Yelp. We identified businesses in the bakery, dessert, and food categories on Yelp with a large concentration of reviews mentioning “pie,” then ranked those spots using a number of factors, including the total volume and ratings of reviews mentioning “pie.”  This list looked at businesses in the United States.  All businesses were marked open on Yelp as of March 1, 2022.

Maui Pie (Kihei, HI)

Alabama (Birmingham): Jawanda’s Sweet Potato Pie

Alaska (Anchorage): A Pie Stop

Arizona (Scottsdale): Sugarjam

Arkansas (Bentonville): Gooseberry Handmade Pies

California (Santa Ysabel): California Mountain Bakery

Colorado (Denver): Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream and Desserts

Connecticut (East Hartford): Granny’s Pie Factory

Delaware (Lewes): Old World Breads

Florida (Jacksonville): Mixed Fillings Pie Shop

Georgia (Atlanta): Southern Baked Pie Company

Hawaii (Kihei): Maui Pie

Mixed Fillings (Jacksonville, FL)

Idaho (Post Falls): Birdie’s Pie Shop

Illinois (Chicago): Spinning j Bakery & Soda Fountain

Indiana (Indianapolis): Pots and Pans Pie Co

Iowa (Cedar Rapids): Kathy’s Pie

Kansas (Overland Park): Upper Crust Pie Bakery

Kentucky (Louisville): Homemade Ice Cream and Pie Kitchen

Louisiana (New Orleans): Windowsill Pies

Maine (Southwest Harbor): Islandbound Treats 

Maryland (Salsibury): The Ugly Pie

Massachusetts (Methuen): Thwaites Market

The Ugly Pie (Salisbury, MD)

Michigan (Holland): Crane’s in the City

Minnesota (Saint Paul): Hot Hands Pie and Biscuit

Mississippi (Jackson): Urban Foxes

Missouri (Kansas City): Ashleigh’s Bake Shop

Montana (Three Forks): Iron Horse Cafe and Pie Shop

Nebraska (Omaha): Modern Love

Nevada (Las Vegas): Sweets Raku

New Hampshire (Woodstock): Woodstock Pie and Coffee

New Jersey (Moorestown): Pie Lady Cafe

New Mexico (Ruidoso): The Village Buttery

Ashleigh’s Bake Shop (Kansas City, MO)

New York (Brooklyn): Miss American Pie

North Carolina (Asheville): Baked Pie Company – Woodfin

North Dakota (Fargo): Nichole’s Fine Pastry and Cafe

Ohio (Lakewood): Rood Food and Pie

Oklahoma (Oklahoma City): Pie Junkie

Oregon (North Plains): The Pie Guy

Pennsylvania (Pittsburgh): The Pie Place

Rhode Island (Providence): Pastiche Fine Desserts

South Carolina (Greenville): Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

South Dakota (Custer): Purple Pie Place

Baked Pie Company -Woodfin (Asheville, NC)

Tennessee (Nasheville): Sweet Creations Pie Bakery

Texas (Fredericksburg): Fredericksburg Pie

Utah (Jordan): Flake Pie Co

Vermont (Chester): The Southern Pie Cafe

Virginia (Richmond): Proper Pie

Washington (Seattle): Cakes of Paradise

West Virginia (Martinsburg): Orrs Farm Market

Wisconsin (Stockholm): Stockholm Pie and General Store

Wyoming (Devils Tower): Devils Tower View

Proper Pie (Richmond, VA)