Yelp’s Top 50 Places to Eat is a list unlike any other “best of” out there. Sure, you’ll see your obvious local favorites on the list, but it’s also chock full of hidden gems and off-the-beaten-path joints like Amaranth Bakery & Cafe tucked away in Walnut Hill Neighborhood. From fine dining to donut shops — find them all in Yelp’s Top 50 Places to Eat in Milwaukee.
Did your favorite restaurant make it into the top 50? Let us know on Twitter and Instagram. Remember, we only know how good a spot is if you take the time to review it. So share your thoughts on Yelp, and maybe your favorites will be on next year’s list!
Topping this year’s best places to eat list is Ono Kine Grindz, a Hawaiian food restaurant on the east side of Wauwatosa, sharing their passion for the cultural diversity and culinary uniqueness of the Hawaiian Islands.
Pro tip: You’re going to want to make a note of these spots, so we made it easy for you. For great businesses at your fingertips, get the Top 50 to-go. Follow this collection on Yelp.
- Ono Kine Grindz (Wauwatosa)
What they’re known for: Hawaiian BBQ
Yelpers say: “Everything on the menu is FIRE. Wonderful meats, flavorful rice, interesting sides. I particularly like the carrot and pineapple slaw and the macaroni potato salad. I recommend getting a combo plate or multiple things to share, because trust me, you’ll want more!” – Nicole L.
- Santino’s Little Italy (Bay View)
What they’re known for: Traditional Neapolitan pizzas
Yelpers say: “The Pizza Paisano with its layered flavors in the tomato-pesto blend and that crumbled spicy Italian sausage just had my mouth flipping! And the cherry tomatoes! Shut the front door! They burst with much flavor for the taste-buds. I was in heaven with this pie.” – Chadrick J.
- Spicy Tuna (West Milwaukee)
Cuisine: Asian Fusion
What they’re known for: Sushi
Yelpers say: “We got a Godzilla roll and when it came out it was the prettiest sushi display I had ever seen! The sushi was awesome and their combination of sauces was even better. We also got fried rice which was amazing and I got the seafood ramen which was some of the best I have ever had!” – Brian H.
- Cosmos Café (Wauwatosa)
What they’re known for: Gyros and other Mediterranean sandwiches
Yelpers say: “I love the way that they finish off the gyro meat on the flat top. It adds a nice little crust to it without drying it out. Also, their tzatzki is an ethereal blend of cucumber and garlic awesomeness.” – Brian M.
- Bento Xpert (Milwaukee)
Cuisine: Taiwanese and Chinese
What they’re known for: Authentic Taiwanese and famous street food
Yelpers say: “Food is absolutely delicious and in large generous portions. Every dish also comes with a tea-braised egg and a variety of vegetables. If you are a first timer, you may want to try their Taiwan Pork Chop bento. Otherwise, Braised Pork belly and three-cup chicken are all very delicious and authentic.” – Lico J.
- Tavo’s Signature Cuisine (Milwaukee)
Cuisine: Mexican and Latin American
What they’re known for: Signature tacos
Yelpers say: “Absolutely phenomenal! I had three tacos, Shrimp, Tinga and Pastor. They were all traditional with the onions and cilantro on corn tortillas. They served the tacos with a verde salsa that was so fresh. I am really looking forward to going back!” – Amanda F.
- Story Hill BKC (Milwaukee)
What they’re known for: Dishes inspired by Upper Midwest ingredients and global technique
Yelpers say: “Whether it’s weekend brunch, co-worker lunch, or dinner, Story Hill BKC can’t be beat! I’ve been here many times for all of the above, and have always been impressed by this gem. Specializing in fresh local ingredients, I’ve never had a bad dish. Short Rib Benny is my fav for brunch.” – Kyle H.
- The Original (Milwaukee)
What they’re known for: Craft cocktails and a unique, monthly rotating menu
Yelpers say: “The charcuterie plate was amazing, paired with craft cocktails – can’t go wrong. The entrees were flavorful and well sized, and the Chef whipped up a beer cheese soup for us! Lastly, save room for dessert, we had one of each that was on the menu… my favorite, cheesecake!” – Annette C.
- Morel (Milwaukee)
What they’re known for: Farm to table
Yelpers say: “Wow, wow, wow. My mind has been blown by the incredible food, the well spoken staff and the lovely ambiance. The food is all so carefully handled and wonderfully prepared. I can’t wait to come back again and again.” – Zack F.
- West Allis Cheese & Sausage Shoppe (West Allis)
What they’re known for: Cheese and meats
Yelpers say: “Every dish is fresh and made to order! You will absolutely be satisfied every time. It’s a New York specialty deli in the middle of West Allis! The food is extraordinary! Flavors that slap your tongue and make your stomach smile. I have never ever ever been dissatisfied.” – Ahnoki D.
- Tosa Bowl and Bun (Wauwatosa)
- Bavette (Milwaukee)
- Mimosa (Franklin)
- Amaranth Bakery & Cafe (Milwaukee)
- Brothers Gyros & Pizza (Hales Corners)
- Damascus Gate Restaurant (Milwaukee)
- FreshFin Poké (Milwaukee)
- Sweet Basil (Franklin)
- Mara’s Grill (Milwaukee)
- Blue’s Egg (Milwaukee)
- Swingin’ Door Exchange (Milwaukee)
- Crave Cafe (Shorewood)
- Twisted Plants (Cudahy & Milwaukee)
- Odd Duck (Milwaukee)
- Cranky Al’s (Wauwatosa)
- Ally’s Bistro (Menomonee Falls)
- Rice N Roll Bistro (Milwaukee)
- Ca’Lucchenzo (Wauwatosa)
- Park Place Cafe (Milwaukee)
- San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana (Milwaukee)
- Lazo’s Taco Shack (Milwaukee)
- Pho Saigon (West Allis)
- St Paul Fish Company (Milwaukee)
- Cavas (Milwaukee)
- Honey Butter Cafe (Franklin)
- Mad Rooster Cafe (Milwaukee)
- Anodyne Coffee Roasting Co (Milwaukee)
- Kin by Rice n Roll (Wauwatosa)
- Boo Boo’s Sandwiches (Milwaukee)
- Beerline Cafe (Milwaukee)
- Hungry Sumo Sushi Bar (Milwaukee)
- Sanford Restaurant (Milwaukee)
- La Merenda (Milwaukee)
- Third Coast Provisions (Milwaukee)
- Uncle Wolfie’s Breakfast Tavern (Milwaukee)
- Anytime Arepa (Milwaukee)
- Nessun Dorma (Milwaukee)
- La Masa Empanada Bar (Milwaukee)
- Bacchus – A Bartolotta Restaurant (Milwaukee)
- R&R Poke (Milwaukee)
Methodology: This is an all-time list of the Top Places to Eat in the Milwaukee area according to Yelp. We identified businesses in the restaurant category on Yelp, then ranked those spots using a number of factors, including the total volume and ratings of reviews. This list looked at businesses in and around the Milwaukee area. All businesses were marked open on Yelp as of May 17, 2022. When available, all businesses on this list have a passing health score as of May 17, 2022.