You scream, I scream, we all scream for… ice cream sandwiches! Whether you like your ice cream sandwich made the traditional way with ice cream wedged between two delicious cookies, or in a non-traditional way like between two donuts, we’ve got the ultimate list of spots for you to explore in celebration of National Ice Cream Sandwich Day on August 2. Be sure to follow our Collection of all the businesses, plus bookmark them on Yelp so you remember to visit them all summer long.
Methodology: This is an all-time list of the Top Ice Cream Sandwich in every state and each Canadian Province according to Yelp. We identified businesses in the food and restaurant category on Yelp, with a large concentration of reviews mentioning “ice cream sandwich,” then ranked those spots using a number of factors, including the total volume and ratings of reviews mentioning “ice cream sandwich.” This list looked at businesses in the United States and Canada. All businesses were marked open on Yelp as of July 11, 2022. When available, all businesses on this list have a passing health score as of July 11, 2022.
United States
- Alabama: Bendy’s Cookies & Cream (Vestavia)
- Alaska: Glacier BrewHouse (Anchorage)
- Arizona: Novel Ice Cream (Phoenix)
- Arkansas: Mo’ Tacos & Churros (Fayetteville)
- California: Ginger Elizabeth Chocolates (Sacramento)
- Colorado: Sweet Action (Denver)
- Connecticut: Roasted (Stamford)
- Delaware: Heirloom (Lewes)
- Florida: Tio Colo (Hialeah)
- Georgia: Leopold’s Ice Cream (Savannah)
- Hawaii: Uncle’s Handmade Ice Cream (Kaneohe)
- Idaho: Flour Child (Boise)
- Illinois: Offset BBQ (Chicago)
- Indiana: TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth (Indianapolis)
- Iowa: Thelma’s Treats (Des Moines)
- Kansas: Blue Chip Cookies & Ice Cream (Leawood)
- Kentucky: Louisville Cream (Louisville)
- Louisiana: Sweet Handkraft (Metairie)
- Maine: Eventide Oyster Company (Portland)
- Maryland: Liquid Assets (Ocean City)
- Massachusetts: Cookie Monstah – Food Truck (Danvers)
- Michigan: Treat Dreams (Ferndale)
- Minnesota: Milkjam Creamery (Minneapolis)
- Mississippi: Delta Dairy (Cleveland)
- Missouri: Betty Rae’s Ice Cream (Kansas City)
- Montana: Roadhouse Diner (Great Falls)
- Nebraska: Coneflower Creamery (Omaha)
- Nevada: Hobak Korean BBQ (Las Vegas)
- New Hampshire: Red Rover Creamery (Portsmouth)
- New Jersey: Milk Sugar Love (Jersey City)
- New Mexico: Rude Boy Cookies (Albuquerque)
- New York: Jacques Torres Chocolate (Brooklyn)
- North Carolina: The High Test Deli And Sweet Shop (Bryson City)
- Ohio: Mason’s Creamery (Cleveland)
- Oklahoma: Sweets & Cream (Tulsa)
- Oregon: Swiss Hibiscus (Portland)
- Pennsylvania: Weckerly’s Ice Cream (Philadelphia)
- Rhode Island: Tricycle Ice Cream (Providence)
- South Carolina: Chow Daddy’s (Hilton Head Island)
- South Dakota: Stensland Family Farms (Sioux Falls)
- Tennessee: Mad Dog’s Creamery & Donuts (Gatlinburg)
- Texas: Launderette (Austin)
- Utah: The Penguin Brothers (Provo)
- Vermont: Elixir Restaurant (White River Junction)
- Virginia: Bake Shop (Arlington)
- Washington: Hello Robin (Seattle)
- Washington D.C.: Baked and Wired
- West Virginia: Old Spruce Cafe and Tavern (Snowshoe)
- Wisconsin: Black Twig Bakery (Wauwatosa)
- Wyoming: Bin22 (Jackson)
Canada
- Alberta: Yelo’d Ice Cream (Edmonton)
- British Columbia: Beta5 Chocolates (Vancouver)
- Ontario: Bang Bang Ice Cream (Toronto)
- Nova Scotia: 2 Doors Down (Halifax)
- Quebec: Dalla Rose (Montreal)
